see how Azad Kashmiri resources are looted:
http://www.jammukashmir.tv/player/News-Update/PRECIOUS-STONES-OF-VAADI-E-NEELUM-DISCOLOSED-BY-THIS-GOVT-.html
My blog provides alternative view on Kashmir dispute and politics of South Asia, especially India Pakistan relations. It aims to educate people that they can make informed judgements.
Thursday, 31 January 2013
Kargil operation discussed and exposed on Capital Talk:
Kargil operation discussed and exposed on Capital Talk:
http://www.zemtv.com/2013/01/31/capital-talk-on-geo-news-col-r-ashfaq-hussain-air-marshall-r-shahid-latif-lt-gen-r-talat-masood-31st-january-2013/
Saturday, 19 January 2013
Kashmir dispute and right to travel
Kashmir
dispute and right to travel
Dr Shabir Choudhry 19 January 2013
It was sad to note that
respectable citizens of State of Jammu and Kashmir, Vijay Abrol and Darvinder Singh Behal were arrested and harassed by Pakistan’s
secret agency, ISI that is known as ‘state within state’ and that has no
respect for human rights. It is unfortunate that citizens of Jammu and Kashmir
are forcibly divided by India and Pakistan and we have to obtain a visa for
either India or Pakistan if we wish to visit the other part of the State. Both Vijay Abrol and Darvinder Singh Behal reside in Jammu, and entered
Pakistan on a valid visit visa; and yet they were arrested because the
Pakistani establishment and their puppets have little respect for human rights
and legal documents.
Right to
assemble and right to movement (travel) are fundamental human rights. By
illegally arresting these guests of people of Azad Kashmir, authorities have
violated: Universal Declaration of Human
Rights; the UNCIP Resolutions, Pakistani Law, International Law and Islamic
Law. It won’t be possible to give details of all laws mentioned above; however,
I will quote relevant sections of the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights, article 13 of which states:
1) ‘Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the
borders of each state.’
2)
The
authorities are also in breach of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights article 2, which
states:
‘Everyone
is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration,
without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion,
political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other
status. Furthermore, no distinction shall be made on the basis of the
political, jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory
to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing
or under any other limitation of sovereignty.’
Those who arrested these guests
and respectable citizens of Jammu and Kashmir demonstrated that their action
was also discriminatory and communal in nature. In the past, especially after
July 1988, Muslim Kashmiris came in thousands by crossing the LOC without any
documents, and authorities and the secret agencies of Pakistan welcomed them
with open arms just because they wanted to get arms, training and funds that
they can go back to fight Indian army in Kashmir.
Darvinder Singh Behal and Vijay Abrol, on the other hand were non Muslims and came here with a
message of peace. They represented Jammu and Kashmir Peace Forum and
wanted to promote peace, good will and better understanding among the forcibly
divided people. The local people welcomed them and held various functions in
their honour. Their message was very encouraging
and advanced the cause of peace and unity. Darvinder Singh Behal said:
‘We people of Jammu and Kashmir are one nation; and we want to be united
and live as a nation. We are one and must remain one.’
He further said: ‘Attempts are being made to divide people of
Jammu and Kashmir in name of religion. The Kashmir dispute is not religious in
nature. It is a political issue and must be resolved peacefully. The use of
force will not help us to resolve this issue.’
On issue of All Parties Hurriyet Conference which is promoted by Pakistan as a representative of the people of Jammu and Kashmir, Darvinder Singh Behal said:
‘Hurriyet Conference does not represent people of Jammu and Kashmir.
They don’t represent people of Jammu, people of Ladakh, people of Gilgit
Baltistan and people of Azad Kashmir. One can say, at best, they represent
people of the Valley of Kashmir’.
Those who arrested Darvinder Singh Behal and Vijay Abrol did not appreciate the agenda they were
promoting. However, their message was very well received by all peace loving
people here. Azad Kashmiri civil society, political parties and newspapers
arranged various functions to promote this message of peace and co existence;
and those who advanced communalism and hatred were alarmed by this. They did
not like their presence and their message, as they thought this message of
peace, love and coexistence was a serious threat to their agenda.
Furthermore, they thought the kind
of welcome these people had in Azad Kashmir would encourage other people from
there to visit this region, and that could strengthen the bond among the divided
people. Interaction between the divided people would surely result in better
understanding and boost the Kashmiri nationalism. The prospect of an
independent Jammu and Kashmir, peace and harmony is against their interests; so
despite the valid documents they arrested them. They also arrested Arif Shahid,
President of Jammu Kashmir National Liberation Council, who was taking them
from Mirpur.
The secret agencies thought this
harassment and intimidation would send a clear signal that they don’t want
anyone coming from there with a message of peace and coexistence; and they
don’t want anyone from Azad Kashmir to accommodate them and promote this kind
of message. Furthermore, they don’t want anyone to criticise their sponsored
Hurriyet Conference and expose them.
This strategy proved to be counter
productive, as civil society of Azad Kashmir, political parties and ordinary
members of the society strongly opposed this; and demanded their immediate
release. Demonstrations were held in various towns of Azad Kashmir condemning
the arrests and demanding their immediate release. This show of strength and
strong resentment forced the authorities to release the visitors. However, Arif
Shahid was released a day after, may be just to make him realise that his crime
of providing a lift to these guests was very serious.
The arrests were made on flimsy charges that their
visas were only for Pakistan. If this claim has any merit then one may ask, why
Muslims who crossed over the LOC to obtain weapons and training were not
arrested; and why they were welcomed, accommodated and dignified. Furthermore,
Hurriyet Conference or other Muslim leaders when they visit Pakistan, why they
are allowed to visit Azad Kashmir and provided with full protocol?
In a case reported as
Ayub Azeez Khan V Jammu and Kashmir Council (PLD 1995 Azad J&K1), citizens
of Jammu and Kashmir from the Indian control Kashmir entered Pakistan on Indian
passports and then shifted to Azad Kashmir. They sought directions from the
High Court that they should not be pushed ‘back to Indian held Kashmir’, and
should be allowed to reside in Azad Kashmir permanently. The High Court
observed that they had ‘valid right to reside in any part of the Azad Kashmir,
and thus, they could not be forcibly deported to Indian held Kashmir’. It was
further observed that ‘the mode of travelling on passports could not place
embargo on the vested rights of the State Subjects to reside permanently in
Azad Kashmir’.
So one can see from the above that the secret
agencies of Pakistan had ulterior motives in arresting these people; and that it
was clearly human rights violation aimed at inflicting fear and intimidation. I
urge both India and Pakistan to ease visa restrictions and open all traditional
routes linking the former Princely State of Jammu and Kashmir that people of
the divided State could interact and trade with each other. This process will
help to promote peace and stability and find amicable solution of the Kashmir
dispute.
Also I urge people of Jammu and Kashmir to continue
their struggle for fundamental rights, including unfettered right to determine
their future that we can live as a nation and protect our history, culture and
identity. I further request them to visit the regions divided by the LOC and
build bridges of understanding to promote peace, stability and unification of
the State of Jammu and Kashmir.
Writer
is a political analyst and author of many books and booklets. Also he is
Director Institute of Kashmir Affairs.Email:drshabirchoudhry@gmail.com
Sunday, 13 January 2013
5 years after Kashmir girl's rape-murder, family waits for justice
5 years after Kashmir
girl's rape-murder, family waits for justice
Srinagar: Since July 2007, Abdul Gani Shah has been juggling
a pile of legal documents, horrifying eye-witness statements and painful
memories as he fights to get the men who allegedly gang-raped and murdered his
14-year-old daughter punished. More than five years later, he says is nowhere
close to getting justice.
The body of Mr Shah's daughter - an eighth standard girl - was found in Langate area of north Kashmir. The family says even fast-tracking the case has not helped.
"Four men abducted her on way from school and raped her. They slit her throat and dumped her body," says Iqbal Ahmad, the girl's brother.
The body of Mr Shah's daughter - an eighth standard girl - was found in Langate area of north Kashmir. The family says even fast-tracking the case has not helped.
"Four men abducted her on way from school and raped her. They slit her throat and dumped her body," says Iqbal Ahmad, the girl's brother.
"The case was initially
heard thrice a week and we had hoped it would be completed very soon. In the
second year, the hearings were twice a week and later once in 15 days. Five
years have passed like this," he says.
The case, like the 23-year-old medical student's gang-rape in Delhi last month, had evoked massive protests in Kashmir. The four suspects were arrested. Bite marks of the girl on them helped the police establish their crime.
The Jammu and Kashmir government, then led by Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad, instituted a bravery award for children in the girl's name. It even promised the family a quick trial and compensation - assurances that have turned out to be empty.
Mr Shah says he doesn't want compensation anymore. "My only demand is that the rapists should be hanged," he says.
His family and relatives are fighting another legal battle. At least 20 people who took part in the protests against the gang-rape-murder are still facing police cases.
"We were only demanding justice, but have been blamed for disturbing law and order," says Masood Ahmad, the girl's other brother.
The case, like the 23-year-old medical student's gang-rape in Delhi last month, had evoked massive protests in Kashmir. The four suspects were arrested. Bite marks of the girl on them helped the police establish their crime.
The Jammu and Kashmir government, then led by Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad, instituted a bravery award for children in the girl's name. It even promised the family a quick trial and compensation - assurances that have turned out to be empty.
Mr Shah says he doesn't want compensation anymore. "My only demand is that the rapists should be hanged," he says.
His family and relatives are fighting another legal battle. At least 20 people who took part in the protests against the gang-rape-murder are still facing police cases.
"We were only demanding justice, but have been blamed for disturbing law and order," says Masood Ahmad, the girl's other brother.
Saturday, 12 January 2013
KNP demand immediate release of guest Kashmiri leader from Jammu.
KNP
demand immediate release of guest Kashmiri leader from Jammu.
London
12 January 2013
Pakistan’s secret
agency, ISI known for its gross human rights violations has arrested Darvindar Sing Behal while he was entering
Pakistan from Mirpur on the Mangla Bridge. Darvindar Sing Behal entered
Pakistan on a valid visit visa, but who cares about valid visa in POK and in
land of pure. Another Kashmiri leader Arif Shahid was also taken by the ISI.
Vijay
Abrol and Darvinder Singh Behal are peace loving people from Jammu and
wanted to promote good will and better understanding among the forcibly divided
people. They entered Pakistan on a valid visit visa and attended various
functions arranged by the local people in their honour.
The
message Darvinder Singh Behal and his colleague gave was very encouraging and
advanced the cause of peace and unity. Darvinder Singh Behal said, ‘We people of
Jammu and Kashmir are one nation; and we want to be united and live as a nation.’
He said, ‘Attempts are being made to divide us in name of religion. We are one
and must remain one.’
‘Hurriyet
Conference does not represent people of Jammu and Kashmir, at best they
represent people of the Valley of Kashmir,’ he added.
Ifzal
Suleria, Zonal President of Kashmir National Party, while talking to Dr Shabir
Choudhry said: ‘Darvinder Singh Behal’s message was very well received by all
peace loving people here; but those who promoted communalism and hatred did not
like this message. ISI did not like their presence and their message and wanted
to punish them and deter others to visit POK’.
Ifzal Suleria
further said, during Darvinder Singh Behal’s stay in Muzaffarabad he had a number of phone calls from secret
agencies and their tone was intimidating. KNP with help of other parties held a
peaceful protest in Muzaffarabad and demanded immediate release of Darvinder
Singh Behal and Arif Shahid.
Darvinder
Singh Behal was our guest and what ISI has done is against Islamic laws and the
UN Resolutions which grant us a right of travel. It is also against
international law; and even against Pakistan’s own laws; but does the ISI care
for any laws?
All
freedom loving people, human rights activists and human rights organisation
must act now to save lives of these people.
KNP
leaders, Abbas Butt, Zubair Ansari, Sarwar Hussain, Basharat Khan, Asim Mirza,
Nawaz Majid, Yasin Anjum, Ishtiaq Hussain, Abdul Ghaffar Shapal, Sabir Hussain
and others strongly condemn this act and demand immediate release of Darvinder
Singh Behal and Arif Shahid.
Dr
Shabir Choudhry Tel.
0044 7790 942471
Email: Drshabirchoudhry@gmail.com
Tuesday, 8 January 2013
Dr Qadari on Jihad in Kashmir
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=464843330230567&set=vb.493879220646341&type=2&theater
This gives me immense satisfaction
This gives me immense satisfaction
People with vested interest and their foot soldiers attack me, abuse me
and ridicule me from time to time. Their aim is to deter me from the valuable
work I am doing to promote the cause of Kashmir. I acknowledge sometimes their
barrage of unwarranted criticism also affects me, as I am also human being with
feeling. However, many students around the globe who benefit from my research
and work make my day. I received the following email from a non Kashmiri
student from University of Coloumbia who is doing some research on the Kashmir
conflict.
Dear Dr. Shabir Choudhry,
I have no words to thank you for extending your support to write my
thesis on Kashmir conflict. I really appreciate it. Thank you so much for your
kindness!
I'm reading the articles you send me and I find them very
useful. Now I can understand the crisis even better.
Hope that this year you will be able to achieve your goals in life and I
also wish for a peaceful solution to Kashmir very soon!
Wish you a Happy new Year!
-Best Regards-
Dilini Gunasekera
Dilini Gunasekera
Kashmiri struggle in 2013
Kashmiri
struggle in 2013
Dr Shabir Choudhry 08 January 2013
It was in 1988, a
Pakistani sponsored militancy started in the Valley of Kashmir, apparently to
‘liberate Kashmir’. However, later events and evidence proved that those who sponsored
the militancy had other agenda and ‘liberation of Kashmir’ was only used as a
ploy to woo Kashmiri youths to pick up guns against India. In this militant
struggle tens of thousands of Kashmiri people have lost their lives, women have
lost their dignity and honour; and thousands of people are still unaccounted
for. Sad thing is that despite so much destruction and human suffering we are
nowhere near the goal of independence; if anything, people are more divided,
leaderless and frustrated.
Some
Kashmiri people have understood that they were used to protect and promote
sovereign interests of Pakistan; and people of Jammu and Kashmir were used as a
raw material in the competing interests of India and Pakistan. However, there
are many Kashmiris who are mentally not prepared to acknowledge this bitter
truth, mainly because of their political and commercial interests; and it is
these people who are major hurdle in the path of our independence. Designs of
the Pakistani establishment were in an article by Pakistan’s famous journalist
Hamid Mir like this:
‘Pakistan introduced militancy in
this movement; but contained the militancy to certain areas. When militants
protested against this, they were bluntly told by ISI senior officer, Major
General Iftikhar Hussain Shah that we don’t want freedom of Kashmir, we only
wanted to wound India....From Kargil adventure of 1999 to division of
Hurriyat Conference in 2002, there is a long list of betrayal of Pakistan’s
political and military leadership to the people of Kashmir. A request to this
leadership is, please stop now, if you cannot do anything good for the people
of Kashmir then, at least stop dividing them and making them fight each other.’
1
Pakistani sponsored
militancy has not only brought havoc to the people of Jammu and Kashmir, and
divided them on communal, regional and ethnic lines; but it also brought India
and Pakistan to the brink of a nuclear clash. Over the decades, the militancy
and Pakistani establishment’s selfish attitude and blunders have transformed
fundamental character of the Kashmiri struggle for right of self determination.
India gradually got
upper hand and militancy showed signs of decline; and it was at that time
‘guest militants’ (Jihadis from other countries) were introduced by those who
were calling shots in the Kashmiri struggle. The Pakistani establishment
continued to support militancy but after 9/11 and ‘War on Terrorism’ it was no
longer possible to overtly support the militants; and they ditched Kashmiris
just like they ditched the Afghans.
Many experts on Indo Pakistan assert that the
Pakistani policy was to bleed India with many wounds, and bring its foe to
knees. Reality is that India, despite these ‘wounds’, has made tremendous
advancement in many fields; and it is Pakistan that seems to be in serious
trouble as a nation state. Pakistani academic and thinker Dr Pervaiz Hoodbhoy,
while analysing the Pakistani policy asserted:
‘Pakistan bleeds from a thousand cuts. If things had gone according to
plan it is India that should have been hurting now, not Pakistan. The army’s 25
years-old low-cost, high-impact strategy of covert warfare would have liberated
Kashmir and secured Afghanistan from Indian influence. Instead, a fierce
blowback has led to a daily pileup of shaheeds, the casualties of a plan that went awry. The morale of
a fine fighting force plummets still further when its soldiers are ordered to
fight those coreligionists who claim to be fighting for Islam. The reported
refusal of some military units to confront the Taliban during last year’s South
Waziristan operation is said to have shocked senior officers and severely
limited their battle options in North Waziristan.’ 2
However, anger against
India is still strong, especially in the Valley because of human rights abuses,
humiliation and suffering; but militancy has considerably declined. People of
Jammu and Kashmir are increasingly realising that they were used as a raw
material to protect and advance Pakistani interests. With militancy
considerably under control, some kind of normalcy is returning to the Valley;
and that does not suit people with vested interests, and those who have made
the ‘struggle’ in to a lucrative business.
Normalcy in Jammu and
Kashmir and peace between India and Pakistan does not suit some powerful
forces, as their interests only flourish when there is instability, violence
and hatred. In view of this, my fear is that these powerful forces will ensure
that the Kashmir pot boils again. People with vested interest could be secretly
planning their next move which could again engulf the Valley in the coming
months and destabilise the peace process and the entire region. I feel once
again they will use religious card to generate hatred and start a new phase of
the struggle.
It must be noted that
there are millions of young men in Pakistan who have ‘graduated’ from religious
schools and there are no employment opportunities there for them other than to
promote ‘jihad’, their brand of Islam and religious hatred. Furthermore, after
withdrawal of NATO forces from Afghanistan tens of thousands of young men will
become ‘jobless’; and they would need a new war theatre to pursue their
ambitions to promote jihad and pursuit of Heaven and Hoors (Heavenly virgin
women). ‘Jihad in Kashmir’ is still an attractive slogan, and will attract many
jihadi warriors; but it will surely add to suffering and miseries of the people
of Jammu and Kashmir.
Over the year Pakistani
establishment’s resolve to interfere in matters of Jammu and Kashmir have
weakened; and they with help of their Kashmiri supporters are trying to make China
part of the Kashmir dispute. China was never part of the Kashmir dispute even though
there is considerable area of the State of Jammu and Kashmir under their
illegal occupation. This move is not designed to help the Kashmir cause or the
people of Jammu and Kashmir; but to further complicate the Kashmir dispute. In
view of loyal sons of soil this move is very dangerous and detrimental to
unification and independence of Jammu and Kashmir.
However, it is good to
note that majority of Kashmiri parties now believe that the struggle for
independence should be peaceful one; and that militancy is not the way forward.
However, it must be pointed out that my colleagues and I advocated peaceful
struggle more than a decade ago. I wrote a number of articles in support of
political and diplomatic struggle; and sad thing is at that time I was accused
of being, ‘anti jihad’, ‘anti Islam’ and ‘anti movement’. I wish those in
position of power had listened to this at that time then we could have saved
many valuable lives.
With the above
background we enter the New Year 2013, which will be very important for
politics of South Asia. Pakistan is getting deeper in to their internal
problems and there are very serious threats to body politics of the country. It
is an established tradition of the Pakistani rulers that when they find it
difficult to control internal troubles they like to divert attention by starting
some external adventures. I hope that they don’t start another direct or
indirect adventure in Kashmir or in India – Mumbai 2, as it would get Pakistan
deeper in the mud.
APHC is still in two
factions and both factions claim to represent people of Jammu and Kashmir; and
are more ‘loyal’ to Pakistan than to State of Jammu and Kashmir. Their
opposition to each other and point scoring does not help the Kashmir cause or
help to relieve miseries of the suffering people. Other pro freedom parties are
also in tatters. The much talked unity of two groups of JKLF (Amanullah Khan
Group and Yasin Malik Group) still leave many JKLF groups working
independently; and as predicted, even this ‘unity’ has produced a split in the
form of Sardar Saghir Khan and his colleagues. Sardar Saghir Khan, former
Chairman of JKLF openly defied this ‘unity’ and called it handiwork of Pakistani
secret agencies.
Without going in to
details who caused these splits, fact is that all nationalist Kashmiri parties
have suffered splits and their meagre resources, time and talent is utilised
either fighting each other or proving that so and so are agents of forces of
occupation. This is not to suggest that there are no agents of forces of
occupation among the nationalists. Reality is that senior leaders of some nationalist
groups are there only to protect and promote interests of either India or
Pakistan; and their role is to confuse nationalists in name of religion or by
spreading communalism, regionalism and hatred.
True nationalists need
to acknowledge this bitter fact that hold of India and Pakistan on both side of
the divide is firmer than ever before. It is also fact that pro Pakistan and
pro Indian parties in their respective parts of Jammu and Kashmir are stronger
than ever before. In view of this prevailing situation, we must formulate our
policies and alliances otherwise both India and Pakistan will enforce some kind
of solution to divide the State of Jammu and Kashmir. And if they do that, are
we in a position to resist it?
In conclusion, year
2013 is going to be very important, not only for people of Jammu and Kashmir,
but also for the entire region of South Asia. However, we people of Jammu and
Kashmir need to keep our eyes and ears open that, once again, we don’t become
tools and victims of our neighbours quest for resources and territory.
References:
3. Writer is a political analyst and author of many books and
booklets. Also he is Director Institute of Kashmir Affairs.Email:drshabirchoudhry@gmail.com
Saturday, 5 January 2013
Road from Kotli to Rajori - now divided by LOC:
Road from Kotli to Rajori - now divided by LOC:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsKW5Yd-l-8
This is a recording of KNP function held in Luton, England. We thank Talat Butt for his help and support in this regard.
This is a recording of KNP function held in Luton, England. We thank Talat Butt for his help and support in this regard.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-9FzY2Tje4&feature=youtu.be
https://www.facebook.com/messages/kashmiria