Tuesday, 17 November 2026

A POLITICAL ROADMAP FOR JAMMU AND KASHMIR Learning from the Past, Understanding the Present and Preparing a Strategy for the Future, by Dr Shabir Choudhry

 A POLITICAL ROADMAP FOR JAMMU AND KASHMIR

Learning from the Past, Understanding the Present and Preparing a Strategy for the Future

Discussion paper prepared by Dr Shabir Choudhry, a member of the United Kashmir People’s National Party, London.

<<<<<<  >>>>>>

 

The purpose of this roadmap is therefore not simply to propose a way of resolving a territorial dispute. It is to explore a way of restoring political dignity, human relationships, democratic rights and hope to the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

 

<<<<<<  >>>>>>

 

Jammu and Kashmir needs a political settlement that resolves the dispute without creating new injustices. Its people deserve peace without humiliation, unity without coercion, democracy without discrimination and a future in which their rights and aspirations are respected.

<<<<<<  >>>>>>

Dedication

This work is dedicated to the people of Jammu and Kashmir, particularly the countless families who have endured the pain and suffering of a forcibly divided homeland.

It is dedicated to mothers who have spent decades waiting for sons and daughters they may never see again; to fathers who have grown old carrying the sorrow of separation; to husbands and wives divided by artificial boundaries; to brothers and sisters, grandparents and grandchildren, whose family bonds have been disrupted by political decisions beyond their control.

It is dedicated to all those who have sacrificed their lives, those who have lost loved ones, and those innocent people who have suffered torture, imprisonment, enforced disappearances, displacement, humiliation and other forms of injustice. It remembers the victims of violence, the families still searching for answers, and those whose suffering has remained unheard or forgotten.

It also honours the courage and resilience of ordinary people who, despite decades of conflict, uncertainty and hardship, have continued to hope for peace, dignity, justice and a better future for coming generations.

This dedication is not confined to any particular region, religion, community or political affiliation. The pain of separation, the loss of innocent lives and the denial of fundamental human rights have affected people across the entire former princely State of Jammu and Kashmir.

Above all, this work is dedicated to the generations who have inherited a conflict they did not create but whose consequences they continue to bear.

May their sacrifices not be forgotten, their suffering not be ignored, and their hopes for a peaceful, united and prosperous future never be abandoned.

 

<<<<<< END >>>>>>

Contents

1.   Prologue

2.   Executive Summary

3.   Letter Seeking a Practical Roadmap for the Freedom of Jammu and Kashmir

4.   My assessment of the question

5.   A political roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir

Learning from the Past, Understanding the Present and Preparing a Strategy for the Future:

1.   Introduction: Why do we need a new roadmap?

2.   Understanding the historical and political background

3.   Why have previous approaches failed to achieve their objectives?

3.1        Overdependence on external governments

3.2        The armed struggle and its consequences

3.3        Weaknesses in international diplomacy

3.4        Failure to establish a credible common political platform

3.5        Personal ambitions and organisational divisions

3.6        Failure to develop a sustainable political and economic programme

4.   The question of collaboration, political loyalty and accountability

A.   Historical collaboration

B.   Contemporary collaboration and political influence

C.   Evidence and accountability

5.   Defining the political objective

6.   Establishing a new political platform

6.1        A common political declaration

6.2        A representative structure

6.3        A professional secretariat

7.   Developing a comprehensive international strategy

7.1        The United Nations

7.2        International human rights organisations

7.3        Governments and parliaments

7.4        The Kashmiri diaspora

8.   A new approach to public communication and political education

A.   A research and documentation centre

B.   Publications in different languages

C.   A professional media programme

D.  A political education programme

9.   Economic and constitutional preparation

10.                 A programme of peaceful political mobilisation

11.                 A phased implementation plan

12.                 Measuring progress

13.                 The question of unity: Unity around principles, not personalities

14.                 What must we do about those who undermine the movement?

15.                 What should be avoided in the future?

16.                 Immediate priorities: What should happen now?

17.                 My concluding observations

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>>

 

Acknowledgements

This document, A Political Roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir, has been prepared in response to a request from a political colleague who considered it important to explore a constructive way forward for resolving the longstanding Jammu and Kashmir dispute.

I am grateful for this initiative, as it provided an opportunity to revisit an issue that has remained unresolved for decades and to examine possible political approaches that could help bring an end to the prolonged suffering of the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

The preparation of this roadmap has involved reflecting upon the historical background of the dispute, its political and legal dimensions, the positions of the parties concerned, the aspirations of the people and the lessons that can be drawn from previous attempts to find a settlement.

I also acknowledge the contribution of those political thinkers, writers, researchers, human rights advocates and individuals who, through their work and commitment, have kept the Jammu and Kashmir question alive in international political discussions. Their arguments, research and experiences have contributed to a wider understanding of the complexities of this dispute.

I recognise, in particular, the efforts of those who have continued to advocate peaceful political engagement, democratic rights, human dignity and a just resolution, despite political differences, personal difficulties and decades of uncertainty.

This document is my contribution to that continuing debate. Its proposals and conclusions are presented for consideration, discussion and constructive criticism. I do not claim that every recommendation is beyond debate or that the roadmap represents the views of every political organisation or individual concerned with Jammu and Kashmir.

I welcome thoughtful suggestions, alternative proposals and constructive criticism that could strengthen this initiative and make it more practical and acceptable to the people concerned.

Finally, I dedicate this effort to the people of Jammu and Kashmir, particularly those who have suffered because of the division of their homeland, the separation of families, the loss of innocent lives, displacement, imprisonment, torture and the denial of fundamental rights.

Their suffering must not be forgotten, and their future must not be decided without their meaningful participation.

My sincere hope is that this document will contribute, however modestly, towards a peaceful, democratic, dignified and lasting political settlement of the Jammu and Kashmir dispute.

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>

1.   Prologue

The Need for a New Political Approach

Jammu and Kashmir is not simply a geographical territory or a disputed piece of land between two neighbouring countries. It is a homeland with a distinct historical, political and cultural identity, inhabited by people whose lives, rights, aspirations and future have been profoundly affected by a conflict that has remained unresolved for generations.

For decades, India and Pakistan have maintained competing positions over Jammu and Kashmir. Their political and strategic rivalry has influenced the region's history, divided its territory and subjected its people to prolonged uncertainty, insecurity and suffering. Numerous political initiatives, bilateral negotiations, international discussions and diplomatic efforts have taken place, yet a lasting settlement remains elusive.

In the meantime, generations have grown up under the consequences of this unresolved dispute. The division of the former princely State has separated families, disrupted communities, restricted movement and weakened historical and social connections. Parents have been deprived of opportunities to meet their children, brothers and sisters have grown old without seeing one another, and many families have carried the pain of separation throughout their lives.

The human cost extends far beyond divided families. Thousands of people have lost their lives in conflict and violence. Many others have experienced displacement, arbitrary detention, imprisonment, torture, enforced disappearance, political repression and other violations of fundamental rights. Innocent civilians have paid an enormous price for political and military decisions over which they have had little or no influence.

These are not merely historical statistics or political arguments. Behind every loss of life, every disappearance, every imprisonment and every separated family is a human story of suffering, uncertainty and unfulfilled hopes.

The passage of time has not resolved the conflict. Instead, it has created new political, economic, social and demographic challenges. Young people have inherited a dispute they did not create, while many of those who experienced the original division and subsequent conflicts have grown old without witnessing a satisfactory resolution.

It is therefore necessary to ask an important question: Can the people of Jammu and Kashmir continue to wait indefinitely for a settlement based on political positions that have repeatedly failed to produce a lasting solution?

This roadmap emerges from the belief that the time has come to reconsider established approaches and explore a fresh political initiative. It does not seek to repeat familiar slogans or merely restate the positions of different governments and political organisations. Its purpose is to examine the underlying problems, identify the obstacles to a settlement and propose a constructive framework for moving forward.

The People Must Be at the Centre

One of the fundamental weaknesses of previous approaches has been the tendency to treat Jammu and Kashmir primarily as a territorial or strategic issue between India and Pakistan.

Although both countries have important roles and responsibilities in any settlement, the political future of Jammu and Kashmir cannot be considered exclusively through the interests of these two states. The people whose homeland is at the centre of the dispute must have a meaningful place in the process.

They are not spectators to a political disagreement between neighbouring countries. They are the people whose lives, rights, identity and future are directly affected by its outcome.

A sustainable settlement must therefore recognise their political aspirations, protect their fundamental rights and provide credible arrangements through which their wishes can be expressed and respected.

The people of Jammu and Kashmir are not politically or culturally homogeneous. The former princely State contains different regions, languages, religious communities, cultural traditions and political perspectives. These differences must be recognised and accommodated rather than ignored or suppressed.

Any political proposal that fails to consider this diversity risks creating new grievances while attempting to resolve existing ones.

Moving Beyond the Politics of Division

The division of Jammu and Kashmir has created physical and political barriers, but it has not erased the historical, social and human connections between its people.

A lasting solution should seek to overcome these divisions rather than perpetuate them. The right of families to meet, communicate and maintain relationships should not remain dependent upon political circumstances or the changing relations between governments.

The restoration of human contact, freedom of movement, economic cooperation and social interaction should be treated as essential elements of reconciliation.

Equally important is the need to end violence, political intimidation, arbitrary imprisonment and violations of fundamental freedoms. No political objective can justify the deliberate targeting of innocent civilians, and no lasting settlement can be built upon fear, coercion or collective punishment.

The people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve an environment in which they can express their political views peacefully, organise themselves democratically, pursue their economic interests and live without fear.

The Need for Political Courage and Realism

A political settlement requires more than statements of principle. It requires political courage, flexibility, mutual respect and a willingness to examine proposals that may challenge established positions.

India and Pakistan must recognise that continuing confrontation has not resolved the dispute. Military strength, diplomatic pressure and political rhetoric have not provided a durable answer to the aspirations and grievances of the people.

Likewise, political organisations and leadership within Jammu and Kashmir must be prepared to engage in serious discussions, recognise differing opinions and consider practical arrangements that can bring the parties closer to a peaceful settlement.

A roadmap must be realistic about the political circumstances, the concerns of the governments involved and the complexity of the territory's regional and international dimensions. It must also remain firmly grounded in democratic principles, human rights and the legitimate aspirations of the people.

The objective should not be to replace one form of domination or exclusion with another. It should be to establish a political arrangement that protects the dignity, rights and interests of all communities and regions.

An Invitation to Consider a Way Forward

This document is an attempt to contribute to that process.

It examines the need for a new political approach, considers the responsibilities of the principal parties and seeks to identify a framework through which the Jammu and Kashmir dispute could move towards a peaceful and democratic resolution.

It is not presented as an unquestionable or final blueprint. No single individual or political organisation can claim to possess all the answers to a conflict of this complexity. A meaningful roadmap must be open to examination, discussion, criticism and improvement.

Its proposals should be assessed on their merits, their practicality and their ability to address the legitimate concerns of the people concerned.

Above all, this initiative is based on the conviction that the people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve a future beyond conflict, confrontation and uncertainty. They deserve political dignity, economic opportunity, fundamental freedoms and the right to live together without artificial barriers separating families and communities.

The generations who have suffered must not become a forgotten chapter in the history of South Asia. Their sacrifices, their losses and their aspirations must inform the political decisions that will shape the future.

The purpose of this roadmap is therefore not simply to propose a way of resolving a territorial dispute. It is to explore a way of restoring political dignity, human relationships, democratic rights and hope to the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

The challenge is considerable, but the consequences of continued failure are far greater.

The time has come to move beyond the politics of confrontation and begin a serious discussion about a peaceful, democratic and lasting political future for Jammu and Kashmir.

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>>

 

 

2.   Executive summary

A Political Roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir

Background and Purpose

The Jammu and Kashmir dispute is one of the longest unresolved political conflicts in the contemporary world. Its origins, historical developments and continuing consequences have shaped the political environment of South Asia and caused immense suffering to the people of the former princely State of Jammu and Kashmir.

Since the partition of British India in 1947, Jammu and Kashmir has remained at the centre of competing political, territorial and strategic claims, principally involving India and Pakistan. Despite numerous diplomatic initiatives, bilateral negotiations, international discussions and political agreements, the dispute has not reached a mutually acceptable and lasting settlement.

The consequences have been particularly severe for the people of Jammu and Kashmir. The division of the territory has separated families, disrupted historical relationships, restricted movement and created enduring political, economic and social difficulties. Generations have experienced conflict, insecurity, displacement, violence, imprisonment and violations of fundamental human rights.

This document, A Political Roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir, seeks to examine the reasons why previous approaches have failed to resolve the dispute and to propose a constructive political framework for moving towards a peaceful and democratic settlement.

Its central argument is that Jammu and Kashmir cannot be treated merely as a territorial disagreement between India and Pakistan. The people of the former princely State must be recognised as central stakeholders in determining their political future.

Fundamental Principles

The proposed roadmap is guided by the following principles:

1. The people as central stakeholders

The political future of Jammu and Kashmir must not be determined exclusively through negotiations between India and Pakistan. The people concerned must have a meaningful and effective role in the political process and in determining their future.

2. A peaceful and democratic settlement

The dispute must be resolved through peaceful political engagement, dialogue and democratic means. Violence, terrorism, intimidation and military confrontation cannot provide a sustainable solution.

3. Political rights and human dignity

Fundamental freedoms, including freedom of expression, political association, peaceful assembly and participation in public affairs, must be protected. Human rights and individual dignity must form an essential part of any settlement.

4. Recognition of historical and regional diversity

The former princely State comprises different geographical regions, communities, languages, religious traditions and political perspectives. Any settlement must recognise this diversity and provide appropriate safeguards against discrimination, marginalisation and domination.

5. Reconciliation and restoration of human relationships

The division of the territory has inflicted deep wounds upon families and communities. Reuniting separated families, facilitating travel and communication, restoring social connections and encouraging cooperation across divided regions should be important priorities.

6. Justice and accountability

The suffering of those who have lost family members, experienced torture, imprisonment, displacement or enforced disappearance must not be overlooked. Victims and their families deserve recognition, truth, justice and appropriate remedies.

7. Constructive engagement with India and Pakistan

Both countries have important responsibilities in facilitating a peaceful settlement. Their legitimate security concerns must be addressed through dialogue and political engagement, while recognising that the rights and aspirations of the people cannot simply be disregarded.

8. Economic development and regional cooperation

A peaceful political environment should create opportunities for economic cooperation, trade, investment, tourism, education, infrastructure development and environmental protection. The benefits of peace must reach ordinary people throughout the former State.

9. Credible political and institutional arrangements

A lasting settlement requires a clearly defined political process, appropriate institutional mechanisms, democratic safeguards and guarantees that protect the rights and interests of all regions and communities.

The Way Forward

The roadmap seeks to move the discussion beyond established political positions and examine practical possibilities for resolving the dispute.

It recognises that a settlement cannot be achieved overnight and that political mistrust, historical grievances and competing interests present considerable challenges. However, these difficulties should encourage serious engagement rather than provide an excuse for indefinite continuation of the status quo.

A credible political process must identify the issues requiring agreement, establish appropriate mechanisms for dialogue, address the concerns of all affected communities and develop a framework through which the political aspirations of the people can be meaningfully considered.

India and Pakistan must be encouraged to move away from confrontation towards constructive engagement. Political representatives and organisations from all regions of Jammu and Kashmir must also be prepared to participate in an inclusive and responsible dialogue.

The roadmap is intended to contribute to this discussion and to provide a basis for further examination, debate and refinement.

Overall Objective

The ultimate objective is to help bring an end to the prolonged conflict and establish a peaceful, democratic and dignified political future for Jammu and Kashmir.

The success of any settlement should not be measured simply by whether India and Pakistan reach an agreement. It should also be judged by whether it addresses the grievances of the people, protects their fundamental rights, accommodates regional diversity, restores human relationships and provides future generations with security, opportunity and hope.

This document is therefore an invitation to think beyond established positions, reconsider previous approaches and explore a political solution that places people, peace, justice and democratic principles at its centre.

Jammu and Kashmir needs a political settlement that resolves the dispute without creating new injustices. Its people deserve peace without humiliation, unity without coercion, democracy without discrimination and a future in which their rights and aspirations are respected.

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>>

 

 

3.   Letter Seeking a Practical Roadmap for the Freedom of Jammu and Kashmir

Dear Readers,

It is important to explain that A Political Roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir was prepared in response to a request from a political colleague. For the sake of transparency and to provide readers with the background to this initiative, I have reproduced his written request below:

Letter Seeking a Practical Roadmap for the Freedom of Jammu and Kashmir

Dear Dr Shabir Choudhry Sahib,

Assalamu Alaikum,

I hope you are keeping well and enjoying good health.

I am approaching you once again with a question. I sincerely hope that this time you will find the opportunity to respond.

For quite some time, I have had certain concerns and unresolved questions on my mind. I thought it would be worthwhile to discuss them with a serious-minded friend such as yourself.

When I previously raised this subject with some friends, many tried to respond through lengthy telephone conversations. However, emotional discussions and verbal exchanges are no longer sufficient. We need serious, considered and documented intellectual debate. I therefore decided to put my question to you so that I could benefit from your views and receive a constructive and substantive response.

The problem is that whenever we discuss the freedom of our motherland, the State of Jammu and Kashmir, we tend to start listing the mistakes of past leaders or discussing the lack of unity and agreement among the present leadership. Before long, the discussion turns into mutual accusations and recriminations. I want us to move beyond this traditional cycle.

I should also mention that a group of highly educated and patriotic friends are currently working together on a project of this nature. If you have the time and are interested, you may also be invited to contribute to this serious undertaking.

I would request you to send your response in writing rather than through a telephone conversation. Those who are reluctant to write, or who do not feel confident in their writing skills, may send their views in Urdu through a voice note or audio recording, provided their arguments are presented in a clear, logical and sufficiently detailed manner. We can then transcribe their contributions.

The only condition is that the discussion should focus exclusively on a practical roadmap for the future, rather than past grievances or criticism of previous or present leadership.

The Question

Today, every politically aware person in the State of Jammu and Kashmir has become conscious of the bitter reality that we have tried almost every conceivable means of achieving freedom.

From taking up arms and making the ultimate sacrifice, to placing our trust in Pakistan, hoping for support from numerous other countries and knocking on diplomatic doors; from approaching the United Nations and international human rights organisations, to issuing strong ultimatums to the powers controlling our territory; from prolonged sit-ins and facing the gallows, to the violation of the dignity of our mothers and sisters and the destruction of our economy and businesses—what political, diplomatic or other course of action have we not tried? What sacrifice have we not made?

Despite all this, there is still no visible prospect of freedom for our motherland.

It has become increasingly difficult to expect any fundamental transformation in the traditional leadership, whether past or present. Nor is it realistic to continue placing unrealistic hopes in the possibility of unity among the existing leadership. Repeatedly discussing past shortcomings, blaming one another or digging up old disputes is now a form of self-deception and a waste of valuable time.

It appears that the approaches we have repeatedly relied upon have failed to deliver the desired outcome. We must therefore ask ourselves whether we have exhausted our old methods without developing a sufficiently effective alternative.

If criticising the past or lamenting the shortcomings of present leadership cannot take us forward, the central question is:

Given these difficult and discouraging realities, what practical and effective alternative roadmap remains available to us?

Moving beyond an acknowledgement of past failures, what alternative strategy and practical programme should we adopt immediately to bring future generations closer to the goal of freedom for our motherland?

I request that your response focus on a workable roadmap for the future, rather than past grievances or criticism of political leadership.

Mr Mehboob Kakarvi

Cell no: 00447300427848    Email: kakrvi@gmail.com

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>>

4.   My assessment of the question

There is a fundamental weakness in the way the question has been framed.

It assumes that because many methods have been attempted, and freedom has not been achieved, all those methods have now been exhausted and their doors permanently closed.

I would question that assumption.

For example:

  • Diplomacy has not necessarily failed; the question is whether it has been conducted with a consistent political position, adequate international support and a coordinated strategy.
  • International human rights advocacy has not necessarily failed; the question is whether documentation, accountability and sustained international pressure have been connected to a clearly defined political objective.
  • Political mobilisation has not necessarily failed; the question is whether it has developed durable institutions, public participation and accountable representation.
  • The armed struggle has had devastating human and political consequences, but its historical impact must be assessed separately from peaceful political and diplomatic methods. We should not assume that all methods are interchangeable or that violence should be repeated.

We should distinguish between a strategy that has failed, a strategy that was never properly implemented, and a strategy that was deliberately diverted from its declared objective.

That distinction is essential.

A. We must understand why previous efforts did not achieve their objectives

We cannot develop a credible future strategy without examining the past. This does not mean attacking individuals or insulting former leaders. It means conducting an honest political assessment.

We should examine:

  1. Why did the armed struggle fail?
  2. Why did Pakistan's involvement not lead to the promised outcome?
  3. Why did international diplomacy fail to generate sufficient political pressure?
  4. Why did the United Nations resolutions not result in implementation?
  5. Why did the Kashmiri leadership fail to develop a common political platform?
  6. Why were popular movements unable to establish lasting, accountable institutions?
  7. Why did personal ambitions, factional interests and external influences repeatedly weaken collective efforts?

We must be prepared to acknowledge uncomfortable facts. Without this exercise, a new roadmap risks becoming another declaration of good intentions.

B. Identify the different political actors and their roles

This is an important issue which I would not leave out.

A serious political assessment must distinguish between:

·       Genuine political supporters: Those who consistently work towards the declared objective of the people's right to determine their political future.

 

·       Political collaborators: Those whose political activities, alliances or strategies advance the interests of one of the states exercising control over Jammu and Kashmir, rather than the independently expressed aspirations of its people.

 

·       Political opponents: Those who openly disagree with the objective or advocate a different constitutional or political future.

 

·       Individuals accused of betrayal: Such allegations require credible evidence, not rumours, personal disagreements or political differences.

 

·       Current political actors: Their policies, funding, alliances, public statements and actual political activities should be examined. We must assess what they are doing today, not merely what they claimed to have done in the past.

We should not allow the word unity to become a shield behind which contradictory political objectives are concealed.

Unity around what? Under whose political programme? With what safeguards? And who will be accountable?

These questions must be answered before any meaningful alliance is formed.

C. Establish a clear political objective

Before discussing tactics, we must establish exactly what we are trying to achieve.

For example:

  • What is the proposed political future of the former princely State of Jammu and Kashmir?
  • Is the objective an independent, united and sovereign Jammu and Kashmir?
  • What is the position regarding the territories presently administered by India, Pakistan and China?
  • How will the political rights and wishes of all regions and communities be respected?
  • What constitutional arrangements would protect minorities, religious freedom, democracy and fundamental human rights?

A roadmap without a clearly defined destination is unlikely to provide meaningful direction.

D. Build institutions rather than personalities

Any future initiative should have:

  • A written political programme.
  • A democratic and transparent organisational structure.
  • Clearly defined responsibilities.
  • Financial transparency and independent auditing.
  • A research and policy team.
  • A credible international advocacy programme.
  • Regular public reporting.
  • A mechanism for accountability and resolving disagreements.

No individual or organisation should be above scrutiny.

A Roadmap for Jammu and Kashmir: We Must Learn from the Past Before Planning the Future

I appreciate the intention behind this initiative and agree that the time has come for a serious, documented and constructive discussion about the future of Jammu and Kashmir. We cannot continue repeating the same political arguments, exchanging accusations or expecting different results without examining why previous approaches failed.

However, I respectfully disagree with the suggestion that examining past mistakes amounts to criticising previous leadership or reopening old disputes.

There is a fundamental difference between personal criticism and an objective political assessment. The former may serve no useful purpose, but the latter is essential.

·       How can we prepare a new roadmap without understanding why previous roadmaps did not work?

·        How can we avoid repeating mistakes if we refuse to identify them?

·       And how can we build a credible political movement if we are unwilling to examine the conduct, interests and political strategies of those who claim to represent the people?

We must also be honest about the role of external influences. Jammu and Kashmir is not simply a dispute between India and Pakistan. It is a question involving the political rights and aspirations of the people of the former princely State. Any future strategy must take account of these realities.

I believe our discussion should therefore begin with three fundamental questions:

First: What went wrong?

We need an objective assessment of the political, diplomatic, military and organisational approaches adopted over the decades. We should establish which approaches failed, why they failed, which were compromised, and which might still have relevance under different circumstances.

Second: Who is working towards what objective?

We must examine the political positions, alliances and activities of organisations and individuals, both past and present. Political differences are legitimate, but deliberate collaboration with interests opposed to the declared aspirations of the Kashmiri people cannot simply be ignored. Equally, allegations of betrayal must be supported by evidence.

We must also examine contemporary strategies that may weaken the political position of the people, divide their movement or subordinate their aspirations to the interests of external governments. Such strategies should be challenged through facts, political debate and democratic accountability.

Third: What kind of political and organisational structure do we need for the future?

We need a clearly defined political objective, a credible representative platform, an agreed programme of action and institutions that are transparent and accountable to the people.

My concern is that we should not confuse avoiding personal criticism with avoiding political accountability. Nor should we confuse unity with an agreement to remain silent about fundamental differences.

A meaningful political alliance cannot be built by bringing together people who have contradictory objectives and simply asking them to forget their differences. It must be built around an agreed political destination, common principles and a commitment to the people.

I would therefore suggest that this project should not begin by asking participants to produce an attractive list of future activities. It should begin with an honest assessment of the political situation, the lessons of history and the interests of the different actors involved. Only then can we formulate a realistic and sustainable roadmap.

 

<<<<<< End >>>>>>

 

 

5.   A POLITICAL ROADMAP FOR JAMMU AND KASHMIR

Learning from the Past, Understanding the Present and Preparing a Strategy for the Future

Discussion paper prepared by Dr Shabir Choudhry, a member of the United Kashmir People’s National Party, London.

Introduction: Why do we need a new roadmap?

A JKLF colleague's question to me is important and deserves serious consideration. The people of Jammu and Kashmir have endured decades of political uncertainty, conflict, human suffering, displacement and economic hardship. Generations have grown up with the expectation that their political future would eventually be resolved, yet a lasting solution remains elusive.

Numerous political, diplomatic, constitutional and other approaches have been adopted. People have made enormous sacrifices, and many have devoted their entire lives to the cause of Jammu and Kashmir. However, the political objective has not been achieved.

We must therefore ask an uncomfortable but necessary question: why have so many years of struggle, sacrifices and political activity failed to produce the desired outcome?

This question should not be interpreted as an attempt to insult previous leaders, undermine genuine sacrifices or reopen personal disputes. It is an attempt to understand the political circumstances that have brought us to the present position.

There is little value in producing another declaration, holding another conference or forming another organisation unless we understand the shortcomings of previous efforts and establish a mechanism to avoid repeating them.

A roadmap must be based on political realities, historical lessons, clearly defined objectives, available resources and a realistic assessment of the forces involved.

My central argument is that we do not simply need a new organisation or a new slogan. We need a new political approach, a credible programme, accountable leadership and a sustained strategy.

2. Understanding the historical and political background

Before deciding where we want to go, we must understand how we arrived at the present situation.

The State of Jammu and Kashmir emerged as a political entity under the Treaty of Amritsar in 1846. It had a distinct territorial, political and constitutional history. Its people belonged to different regions, religions, languages and cultural backgrounds.

The events surrounding the end of British rule in 1947 fundamentally changed the political circumstances of the State. The division of British India, the controversy surrounding accession, the outbreak of armed conflict and subsequent international involvement transformed the issue into an international dispute.

The United Nations became involved in 1948. United Nations Security Council Resolution 1948 adopted a plan to resolve the Jammu and Kashmir dispute. The main features are as follows:

·       “As the presence of troops of Pakistan in the territory of the State of Jammu and Kashmir constitutes a material change in the situation since it was represented by the Government of Pakistan before the Security Council, the Government of Pakistan agrees to withdraw its troops from the State.”

 

·        “The Government of Pakistan will use its best endeavour to secure the withdrawal from the State of Jammu and Kashmir of tribesmen and Pakistan nationals not normally resident therein who have entered the State for the purpose of fighting.”

 

·       Once ‘the Pakistan forces are being withdrawn from the State of Jammu and Kashmir, the Government of India agrees to begin to withdraw the bulk of their forces from the State in stages to be agreed upon with the Commission.’

 

·       The Government of India and the Government of Pakistan reaffirm their wish that the future status of the State of Jammu and Kashmir shall be determined in accordance with the will of the people and to that end, upon acceptance of the Truce Agreement both Governments agree to enter into consultations with the Commission to determine fair and equitable conditions whereby such free expression will be assured.

 

·       It must be pointed out that, at Pakistan’s request, the broader expression “future status of the State of Jammu and Kashmir” was replaced by the specific formula “the question of the accession of the State of Jammu and Kashmir to India or Pakistan” in the principles adopted by UNCIP on 5 January 1949.

 

However, some people suggest that our political discussion must go beyond the history of the United Nations and the India-Pakistan dispute.

At the same time, it is imperative that we examine the political aspirations of the people themselves.

An important question is whether the political future of the entire former princely State has been adequately represented in the policies and negotiations conducted by the different parties.

The territories of Jammu, Kashmir Valley, Ladakh, Gilgit-Baltistan and Azad Jammu and Kashmir have different political, geographical and social circumstances. Their people must not be treated as though they have identical experiences or political priorities.

A future political programme must recognise this diversity while addressing the question of the State as a whole.

3. Why have previous approaches failed to achieve their objectives?

I do not believe that every political and diplomatic effort has been completely useless. Some efforts have raised international awareness, preserved historical records, documented human rights concerns and maintained political identity.

Nevertheless, we must acknowledge that these activities have not achieved the ultimate political objective.

There are several areas which require examination.

3.1 Overdependence on external governments

One of the major weaknesses of the Kashmiri political struggle has been its dependence on external governments, particularly India and Pakistan, as well as expectations of support from other powerful countries.

At different times, sections of the political leadership placed considerable confidence in Pakistan. Others expected international governments to intervene and resolve the dispute.

The fundamental problem was that the interests of external governments were not necessarily identical to the political aspirations of the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

States generally conduct foreign policy according to their national interests. They may support a political cause when doing so serves their interests, but their priorities can change.

Consequently, a movement that depends excessively on the goodwill of another government risks losing its political independence and freedom of action.

Our lesson must be that international support is important, but the political direction of the movement must remain accountable to the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

3.2 The armed struggle and its consequences

The armed struggle, whoever was behind it, or whatever its goals were, brought enormous suffering to the people. Thousands of families experienced death, injury, displacement, imprisonment and economic hardship.

It also contributed to the internationalisation of the issue at different stages. However, the existence of armed resistance did not translate into the achievement of the declared political objective.

We must examine its political, social, economic and religious consequences, including the loss of civilian lives, the destruction of social and economic structures, the growth of militarisation, extremism, intolerance and the weakening of independent political organisation.

We should also examine the relationship between armed groups, external sponsorship and the political leadership.

A movement cannot claim to represent the people's democratic aspirations while failing to protect civilians, respect political diversity and maintain independent decision-making.

The future programme should be based on peaceful political participation, democratic mobilisation, human rights advocacy and international diplomacy. Violence against civilians, terrorism and sectarian extremism must have no place in it.

3.3 Weaknesses in international diplomacy

Diplomatic efforts have been undertaken through governments, political representatives, international conferences, overseas organisations and individual activists.

However, these efforts have often lacked coordination, continuity and a clearly defined common programme.

Some individuals and organisations have approached international institutions with different political positions. Others have concentrated on personal contacts rather than developing sustained institutional relationships.

We must also recognise that international institutions do not automatically implement political demands simply because they have been presented to them.

For example, the United Nations has adopted resolutions, and its human rights office has published reports concerning conditions in both Indian-administered and Pakistan-administered parts of the former State. The OHCHR reports of 2018 and 2019 raised concerns about human rights violations, restrictions on freedoms and the conduct of state and non-state actors. They also recommended further action and accountability.

The lesson is that international advocacy must be continuous, properly researched, professionally presented and supported by an organised political strategy.

3.4 Failure to establish a credible common political platform

Another serious weakness has been the absence of a durable and representative political platform capable of bringing together people and organisations around an agreed political programme.

Hitherto, different organisations have followed different objectives, methods and political alliances.

Some have advocated independence with a secular society, some have advocated an Islamic state, accession to Pakistan or India, while some have concentrated on regional autonomy or other constitutional arrangements.

·       These differences cannot be resolved by simply demanding unity.

·       We must first establish what political objective we are trying to achieve.

·       Unity without agreement on the destination is likely to produce further disagreements.

·       A meaningful alliance must be based on clearly defined principles, agreed political objectives and mutual accountability.

3.5 Personal ambitions and organisational divisions

Political movements require leadership, but leadership must serve the cause rather than use the cause to serve personal ambitions. Sadly, some leaders used the name of the struggle and suffering of the people to advance their personal agenda or the interests of those countries which occupy us.

In some political environments, disagreements over positions, titles, representation and organisational control have weakened collective efforts.

We must examine whether personal rivalries, factional interests and competition for recognition have repeatedly taken priority over political objectives.

This is not an accusation against every individual who has held a leadership position. It is an organisational question which deserves honest examination.

A future political structure must be designed in such a way that no individual can monopolise the movement or claim ownership of the aspirations of millions of people.

3.6 Failure to develop a sustainable political and economic programme

For many years, much of the political discussion has concentrated on the question of freedom without adequately explaining what political and economic arrangements would follow.

People have a right to know what kind of State is being proposed.

How would it be governed? How would public resources be managed? What would happen to:

Education,

Healthcare,

Employment,

Trade,

Agriculture,

Tourism,

Industry and

Above all, how would the rights of different regions and communities be protected?

A political movement must be able to answer these questions. Otherwise, it risks remaining a protest movement rather than developing into a credible political alternative.

4. The question of collaboration, political loyalty and accountability

This is an uncomfortable subject, but it cannot be ignored.

We cannot understand the failures of the past or prepare a credible strategy for the future without examining the influence of external interests and the conduct of political actors.

There is a difference between:

·       Someone who disagrees with our political objective,

·       Someone who cooperates with another government for legitimate political reasons,

·       Someone whose strategy objectively benefits an external power, and

·       Someone who knowingly works to undermine the political aspirations they publicly claim to support.

These categories must not be confused.

We should not label every political opponent a collaborator or traitor. Equally, we should not avoid examining credible evidence simply because the subject is uncomfortable.

I propose that an independent political research group examine the following:

A. Historical collaboration

  • Which political individuals and organisations entered into arrangements with external governments?
  • What were the declared objectives of those arrangements?
  • Did those arrangements advance the political rights of the people, or primarily serve the interests of external governments?
  • What evidence exists regarding financial, organisational or political dependence?
  • What were the consequences for the wider movement?

B. Contemporary collaboration and political influence

We must also examine the present situation rather than concentrating exclusively on historical personalities.

  • Which organisations and individuals currently receive political, financial or organisational support from external sources?
  • Are their political programmes independently determined?
  • Do their public statements and actual activities correspond?
  • Are they promoting a political settlement based on the expressed wishes of the people, or subordinating those wishes to the strategic interests of another State?
  • Are they attempting to divide or weaken independent political initiatives?
  • Do their activities encourage political dependence or discourage independent democratic organisation?

C. Evidence and accountability

Any serious allegation must be supported by reliable evidence. Relevant material may include public statements, organisational documents, financial records lawfully obtained, formal agreements and independently corroborated testimony.

Those concerned must have an opportunity to respond.

The purpose should not be to create a list of enemies. It should be to establish political transparency and ensure that people can make informed decisions about whom they trust to represent them.

My position is straightforward:

·       Political differences must be respected,

·       But deliberate deception,

·       Concealed external control and

·       The undermining of the people's political rights must not be protected in the name of unity.

5. Defining the political objective

Before establishing a new strategy, we must agree on the political destination.

If the proposed objective is a united, independent and sovereign Jammu and Kashmir, this must be stated clearly and explained in political, legal and constitutional terms.

The proposed objective should address the following:

  1. Territorial integrity: The political future of the entire former princely State must be considered, including the territories currently administered by India, Pakistan and China.
  2. Right to self-determination: The people must have a genuine opportunity to determine their political future through a peaceful, democratic and internationally credible process.
  3. Democratic government: The proposed State must be founded on representative democracy, constitutional government and the rule of law.
  4. Religious freedom and secular principles: Every citizen must enjoy equal rights irrespective of religion, sect, ethnicity, language or region.
  5. Regional autonomy: The different regions must have meaningful constitutional protection and appropriate powers to manage their local affairs.
  6. Human rights: Fundamental rights, freedom of expression, freedom of association and an independent judiciary must be guaranteed.
  7. Economic justice: Natural resources must benefit the people, and public institutions must operate transparently.
  8. Peaceful relations: The future State must seek peaceful and cooperative relations with its neighbours.

This political objective should be debated openly. It should not be imposed on people without their participation.

We must also acknowledge that the political preferences of the population across the former State cannot simply be assumed to be identical. A credible process must provide space for different views and ensure that all communities and regions are heard.

6. Establishing a new political platform

I do not suggest that another organisation should be established simply to add one more name to the existing list of organisations.

We already have many political parties, associations, committees and individuals working on Jammu and Kashmir.

The question is whether they can agree on a common minimum political programme.

I would propose establishing a Jammu and Kashmir Political Coordination and Strategy Forum, initially as a research and consultation platform rather than immediately declaring it a new political organisation.

Its responsibilities could include:

6.1 A common political declaration

The forum should prepare a concise document setting out:

  • The political objective.
  • The territorial scope of the question.
  • The fundamental rights of the people.
  • The commitment to peaceful democratic struggle.
  • The rejection of terrorism, extremism and violence against civilians.
  • The commitment to secularism, equality and religious freedom.
  • The principle of political independence from external control.
  • The right of every region and community to participate in decisions concerning its future.

Organisations and individuals should be free to examine and endorse the declaration.

6.2 A representative structure

The forum should include people from different regions and communities, including:

  • Jammu.
  • Kashmir Valley.
  • Ladakh.
  • Gilgit-Baltistan.
  • Azad Jammu and Kashmir.
  • Kashmiri communities living abroad.

Representation should not be limited to established political leaders.

Academics, lawyers, economists, human rights defenders, journalists, young people, women and representatives of civil society should also participate.

The purpose should be to broaden political participation rather than create another leadership hierarchy.

6.3 A professional secretariat

The forum should have a small, properly organised secretariat responsible for research, communication, documentation, meetings and implementation.

Its work should be transparent, with published minutes, annual reports and financial accounts.

No individual should have unlimited authority, and leadership positions should be subject to democratic procedures and periodic review.

7. Developing a comprehensive international strategy

The international dimension must remain an important part of the political programme. However, it needs to become more professional, coordinated and consistent.

We should stop treating international conferences and meetings as achievements in themselves. Their value should be measured by what they accomplish.

I suggest the following approach.

7.1 The United Nations

A dedicated team should study the relevant Security Council resolutions, UNCIP documents, subsequent international developments and the legal and political positions of the parties.

We must be careful not to present the existing United Nations framework as though it automatically provides for independence. Resolution 47, for example, addressed a proposed plebiscite on accession to India or Pakistan. Any separate proposal for independence requires its own carefully developed political and legal argument.

The team should prepare a detailed position paper explaining the political aspirations of the people, the history of the dispute and the case for a peaceful and democratic settlement.

7.2 International human rights organisations

We should develop regular working relationships with:

  • United Nations human rights mechanisms.
  • Amnesty International.
  • Human Rights Watch.
  • International Commission of Jurists.
  • Relevant parliamentary human rights groups.
  • Independent legal and academic institutions.

Our submissions must be evidence-based and professionally documented.

Human rights advocacy should cover all parts of the former State, without selective treatment of abuses according to which government or political organisation is responsible.

7.3 Governments and parliaments

The United Kingdom, European countries, the United States, Canada and other relevant governments should be approached through a coordinated programme.

Instead of repeatedly requesting general support, we should present specific proposals.

For example:

  • Support for human rights monitoring.
  • Access for independent international observers.
  • Protection of political prisoners and peaceful activists.
  • Support for freedom of expression and association.
  • Encouragement of meaningful dialogue involving representatives of the people.
  • Support for a peaceful and democratic political settlement.

Each meeting should have a defined purpose, written briefing material and a record of follow-up action.

7.4 The Kashmiri diaspora

The diaspora has considerable potential, but that potential must be organised.

There are Kashmiri communities in Britain, Europe, North America and other parts of the world.

We should develop a network of academics, professionals, businesspeople, students and community organisations.

They should be encouraged to contribute their knowledge, expertise, contacts and resources to a common programme.

The diaspora must not become a substitute for the people living in Jammu and Kashmir. Its role should be to support, amplify and represent their voices internationally.

8. A new approach to public communication and political education

One of our weaknesses has been the absence of a consistent, accessible and professionally managed information strategy.

Political arguments must be communicated in a way that ordinary people, journalists, academics and policymakers can understand.

We need:

A. A research and documentation centre

This should maintain reliable information about:

  • The history of the State.
  • Constitutional and legal developments.
  • Human rights conditions.
  • Economic and demographic issues.
  • Political developments in all regions.
  • International diplomatic developments.

B. Publications in different languages

Research should be made available in English, Urdu, Kashmiri, Pahari, Dogri, Balti and other relevant languages wherever resources permit.

C. A professional media programme

We should develop articles, interviews, press statements, podcasts, documentaries and educational material.

D. A political education programme

Young people should be given opportunities to understand the history of the State, international law, democratic principles, human rights and the different political positions concerning the future.

We should encourage informed discussion rather than demand unquestioning loyalty to any organisation or personality.

9. Economic and constitutional preparation

A serious political movement must explain not only what it wants to achieve but also what it proposes to establish.

We should commission independent research into the economic and constitutional future of Jammu and Kashmir.

The research should cover:

  • Natural resources and their ownership.
  • Water resources and energy generation.
  • Agriculture and food security.
  • Tourism and sustainable development.
  • Education and professional training.
  • Healthcare and public services.
  • Trade and regional economic cooperation.
  • Employment and investment.
  • Infrastructure and communications.
  • Protection of the environment.
  • Public finance and taxation.

A constitutional working group should examine possible arrangements for federal government, regional autonomy, minority protection, judicial independence and local democratic institutions.

These proposals should be published for public discussion.

We should not promise people an unrealistic economic future. We should present credible policies, acknowledge challenges and explain how the proposed arrangements would work.

10. A programme of peaceful political mobilisation

International diplomacy cannot replace political participation by the people themselves.

Equally, political mobilisation must be organised, disciplined and based on democratic principles.

The proposed programme should include:

  1. Public meetings and educational conferences.
  2. Peaceful demonstrations and lawful campaigns.
  3. Petitions and representations to elected institutions.
  4. Community consultations across different regions.
  5. Youth and women's participation.
  6. Human rights campaigns.
  7. Public debates on constitutional and political alternatives.
  8. Cooperation between organisations that accept the agreed minimum programme.

We must also develop a culture in which political disagreement is accepted.

No individual or organisation should claim that it alone represents all the people.

A political movement becomes credible when people can participate freely, question their representatives and hold them accountable.

11. A phased implementation plan

A roadmap must include a timetable. Otherwise, it remains a statement of aspirations.

I suggest the following initial programme.

Proposed timetable: first 24 months, subject to consultation and available resources.

Period

Main responsibilities

Expected outcome

Months 1–3

Consultation, historical review and political assessment

A documented assessment of previous strategies

Months 4–6

Agree political principles and minimum programme

Draft common political declaration

Months 7–9

Establish research teams and representative forum

Functional coordination structure

Months 10–12

Publish legal, historical and economic papers

Evidence-based policy documents

Months 13–15

Develop international advocacy network

Coordinated diplomatic programme

Months 16–18

Expand diaspora and public engagement

Wider public participation

Months 19–21

Develop constitutional and economic proposals

Draft future governance framework

Months 22–24

Review progress and consult the public

Revised and accountable long-term strategy

The timetable should be reviewed every six months. Progress reports should be made public.

12. Measuring progress

We should avoid measuring success simply by the number of meetings held, statements issued or conferences organised.

Instead, we should ask:

  • How many organisations have endorsed the common principles?
  • How representative is the forum?
  • Have reliable research papers been published?
  • Have international institutions responded to our submissions?
  • Have new relationships been established with relevant parliamentary and human rights bodies?
  • Are young people and women participating meaningfully?
  • Is the organisation financially transparent?
  • Are people across different regions engaging with the programme?
  • Have we developed practical proposals for constitutional and economic arrangements?

These indicators would help establish whether the project is making measurable progress.

13. The question of unity: Unity around principles, not personalities

I consider this one of the most important issues.

For many years, people have called for unity among Kashmiri political organisations. Numerous attempts have been made, but lasting unity has remained difficult.

Perhaps we need to reconsider what we mean by unity.

Unity should not mean that every organisation must dissolve itself or that every individual must accept the leadership of another person.

Nor should it mean that people with fundamentally contradictory political objectives should be brought together under one banner without resolving their differences.

I suggest a different approach.

Organisations should be invited to agree on a minimum common political programme while retaining their individual identities.

They should agree on certain fundamental principles:

  • The people of Jammu and Kashmir have a right to participate in determining their political future.
  • No external government should dictate the political aspirations of the people.
  • The future must be determined through peaceful and democratic means.
  • Human rights and fundamental freedoms must be respected.
  • All regions and communities must have meaningful representation.
  • Political organisations must be accountable for their activities and decisions.

Those who agree can work together. Those who disagree should be free to present their alternative positions.

This approach would allow cooperation without demanding artificial uniformity.

14. What must we do about those who undermine the movement?

We should not avoid this question merely because it may cause discomfort.

A political movement cannot function effectively if it has no means of identifying and responding to activities that undermine its declared objectives.

However, our response must be political, lawful and evidence-based.

I propose three measures.

First: Political transparency.

Organisations and their representatives should be encouraged to disclose their political objectives, organisational arrangements, sources of funding where appropriate, and significant external relationships.

Second: Independent scrutiny.

A small independent research group should examine documented cases where political activities appear to conflict with the movement's declared objectives. Its findings should distinguish established facts from allegations and interpretations.

Third: Political opposition to damaging strategies.

Where an organisation or individual promotes a strategy that weakens independent political representation, divides communities or places the movement under external political control, we should challenge that strategy openly.

We should explain why it is harmful, present evidence and offer an alternative.

We must not confuse peaceful political disagreement with collaboration, but neither should we allow the language of unity to prevent legitimate scrutiny.

Our objective should be to protect the integrity of the political process, not to encourage hostility towards individuals.

15. What should be avoided in the future?

There are certain practices which should not be repeated.

  1. Depending on one external government to determine our political future.
  2. Making political promises without a practical implementation programme.
  3. Creating organisations that depend entirely on one personality.
  4. Claiming to represent the entire State without a genuine representative mandate.
  5. Making allegations without evidence.
  6. Treating political opponents as personal enemies.
  7. Confusing the number of conferences and meetings with political progress.
  8. Ignoring the political aspirations of regions outside the Kashmir Valley.
  9. Using religion, sectarian identity or ethnic differences to divide people.
  10. Allowing personal ambitions to take priority over the agreed political objective.
  11. Making unrealistic claims about international support.
  12. Promoting violence, terrorism or intimidation as a substitute for democratic politics.

We should also avoid the temptation to announce that a new initiative has already united the people or represents their collective wishes. Public confidence must be earned through participation, transparency and accountability.

16. Immediate priorities: What should happen now?

I would not suggest that we attempt to implement all these proposals simultaneously.

We should begin with a small number of practical steps.

Priority One: Establish a temporary independent working group.

Invite a limited number of people with relevant experience in history, politics, international relations, law, economics, human rights and public communication.

Their first responsibility should be to prepare a historical and political assessment.

Priority Two: Prepare a political position paper.

The paper should clearly explain the proposed political objective, the territorial question, the rights of the people and the proposed peaceful democratic approach.

Priority Three: Conduct a political stakeholder assessment.

Identify the organisations, political parties, institutions and individuals involved in the issue. Record their declared positions, alliances, activities and areas of agreement or disagreement.

This should include historical and contemporary political influence, with allegations assessed against evidence.

Priority Four: Consult people across the former State and the diaspora.

The project must not become an exercise conducted exclusively by people living abroad or by established political personalities.

Priority Five: Publish a draft roadmap.

Invite criticism, suggestions and alternative proposals. Make necessary amendments before adopting a final programme.

Priority Six: Establish an implementation and accountability mechanism.

Every agreed proposal must have a responsible person or team, a timetable, a budget where necessary and a means of measuring progress.

17. My concluding observations

I believe the people of Jammu and Kashmir have a right to ask their political representatives difficult questions.

They have a right to know why previous strategies did not achieve their objectives, why political divisions continued, why external governments acquired such influence and why so many sacrifices have not produced a satisfactory political outcome.

These questions should not be dismissed as criticism of individuals or an attempt to reopen historical disputes.

We must respect those who made sacrifices, acknowledge those who worked sincerely and learn from those who made mistakes. But respect for sacrifices cannot mean that we abandon critical thinking.

Similarly, we should not automatically assume that everyone who held a leadership position acted in the best interests of the people. Political conduct must be examined objectively.

I would also caution against the belief that all traditional political methods have become permanently useless. Diplomacy, political mobilisation, international advocacy and human rights work remain relevant. What needs to change is the way these methods are coordinated, the independence with which they are pursued and the accountability of those responsible for them.

The future cannot be built by simply repeating the past, but neither can it be built by refusing to study the past.

We must develop a political movement that is:

·       Independent in its thinking,

·       Democratic in its organisation,

·       Peaceful in its methods,

·       Secular in its outlook and

·       Accountable to the people.

Above all, we must understand that the people of Jammu and Kashmir, rather than individual leaders, political parties or external governments, must remain at the centre of any future settlement.

I would conclude with the following observations:

·       We do not need unity at any cost; we need unity around a clearly defined political objective.

 

·       We do not need another generation of political promises; we need a programme with measurable objectives and accountability.

 

·       We do not need to replace one personality with another; we need democratic institutions that are stronger than personalities.

 

·       We do not need to conceal the mistakes of the past; we need to understand them so that future generations do not repeat them.

And finally:

·       The freedom and political future of Jammu and Kashmir cannot be built on: dependence,

·       Confusion,

·       Personal ambitions or

·       Unrealistic expectations.

·       It must be built on political clarity, public participation, democratic principles, international engagement and the determination of its people.

That, in my view, should be the foundation of a new political roadmap.

Dr Shabir Choudhry, London.

Drshabirchoudhry@gmail.com     Cell no: 00447790942471

 

<<<<<<< END <<<<<<

 

 

 

 

 


--
Dr Shabir Choudhry

 Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) said: "Say what is true, although it may be bitter and displeasing to people."